Topic's purpose

Posts : 2392 Join date : 2012-07-25 Location : Greece

Here is the place that any ENP member can make a review for their favourite anime or just for a show that needs discussing and some spotlight.

I'll make a template soonish that you must follow so the review is something we can call preview and to prevent people like Letha who just clicks on "New Topic" and spits out rainbows to spam this section.

Guest

Subject: Re: Topic's purpose Wed Jun 12, 2013 9:38 am

Just anime? or even Manga series? since i'm more of a Manga reader, and have lots of series worth sharing

Posts : 1902 Join date : 2011-09-30 Age : 29

995Gabber wrote:: Just anime? or even Manga series? since i'm more of a Manga reader, and have lots of series worth sharing

because of you.. i now have to rename the section :P

Subject: Re: Topic's purpose Wed Jun 12, 2013 9:42 am

MrPampouks wrote:: because of you.. i now have to rename the section :P

Thank you :determined:

Posts : 2392 Join date : 2012-07-25 Location : Greece

Sorry about the delay,but this is a complicated matter and seeing that only me and maybe Gabber will make any reviews,i'll take my time and make a good template.

Subject: Re: Topic's purpose Thu Jun 13, 2013 2:14 pm

Perhaps we can just leave the review style up to how the reviewer wants to do it?

Posts : 2392 Join date : 2012-07-25 Location : Greece

I want to have something basic out so people know what to follow,because if i remove rainbow stuff i want to tell them "ITS NOT A REVIEW,ITS NOT LIKE THIS" and i shove it in their faces.

Subject: Re: Topic's purpose Thu Jun 13, 2013 3:56 pm

Anime or Manga name:
Creator:
Age Group:
Vintage:
Status: finished or not
Summary: [ you make your own summery of the series ]

and add some pictures !! [ not Spoiler ]

Why did I like the series ?
What's the best thing about the series ?
[ make your own questions ? ]

I think this will work ?

Subject: Re: Topic's purpose Thu Jun 13, 2013 4:08 pm

well i don't think that creator and age group is so important

Subject: Re: Topic's purpose Thu Jun 13, 2013 4:10 pm

nikos150 wrote:: well i don't think that creator and age group is so important

I know right :!: but I was just suggesting things, he can add anything he wants ?

Posts : 2392 Join date : 2012-07-25 Location : Greece

Thanks for the suggestion,but i want to go more in-depth.

Subject: Re: Topic's purpose Thu Jun 13, 2013 4:20 pm

sgtpeterarbit wrote:: Thanks for the suggestion,but i want to go more in-depth.

Oh :O

Like ?

Posts : 2392 Join date : 2012-07-25 Location : Greece

First of all,let's make this clear,no ongoing anime will allowed to be reviewed,this is a joke that can only happen on MyAnimeList (There are exceptions like you can review the first season of an anime while the 2nd season is ongoing.)

You can write your blob of choice rainbows as your opening but afterwards you should have a detailed opinion about animation,character development,pace/plot,sound(including openings/endings/songs in general if you're into that stuff)

Multiple seasons?Write multiple paragraphs contrasting them and present the differences.

I've got more stuff going on but i don't want to go around announcing something that might not be in the final template.

I think Gabber should make his own template for manga reviews if he wants,otherwise i'll make one.

Subject: Re: Topic's purpose Thu Jun 13, 2013 4:38 pm

it's incredibly hard to find a manga that is not on-going :/ since the anime series of a show might end, but the manga of it keeps going. MOST cases I know of a manga ending are because the manga is not doing good sales wise, which obviously means it's not good. so it'd make my life easier if you would allow On-going "Manga" series

Posts : 2392 Join date : 2012-07-25 Location : Greece

That's why i said anime....

Subject: Re: Topic's purpose Thu Jun 13, 2013 4:55 pm

Think that will take a lot of time

Posts : 2392 Join date : 2012-07-25 Location : Greece

It should take a lot of time,it's a review.If you want to summarize your thoughts randomly and post the anime on the forum just go do it in the "Other anime/manga" section
Just on the title,after you put your title insert (My thoughts,spoiler free) or (My thoughts,spoiler under brackets) depending if you will insert spoilers or not.

Subject: Re: Topic's purpose Thu Jun 13, 2013 9:13 pm

okay , so...how was my review for "Zetsuen no Tempest" ??

Posts : 2392 Join date : 2012-07-25 Location : Greece

It's not a review,it's more of a recommendation/my thoughts.If you want you can make a more detailed version which can be called a review and post it here.I don't count my Canaan topic as a review either for the record.

Subject: Re: Topic's purpose Thu Jun 13, 2013 10:33 pm

How about setting it out like MAL ( my anime list )
just make a topic called the name of the anime in the Reviews section.
then we all right a short paragraph or something longer, as long as it contains no spoilers etc.
no spam post just simply reviews only.

Subject: Re: Topic's purpose Thu Jun 13, 2013 10:43 pm

Crookz wrote:: How about setting it out like MAL ( my anime list )
just make a topic called the name of the anime in the Reviews section.
then we all right a short paragraph or something longer, as long as it contains no spoilers etc.
no spam post just simply reviews only.

This is ENP you gotta make things Unique and better :D

Posts : 2392 Join date : 2012-07-25 Location : Greece

Ehh,that's not a review.If you want we can try this on a topic somewhere else.I want to introduce anime you haven't watched,if we do it that way i'll just write a small post and then silence because nobody here's watched it.

Posts : 2392 Join date : 2012-07-25 Location : Greece

Guys sorry,i know that i was supposed to make the template but the army raped me before i could think of something but don't worry i'll formulate something during the scarce free time i have during my training to create a template.

In the meanwhile if someone wants to make an anime review he is free to in whichever way possible,keep spoilers to a minimum-none level though.