THE END ! (Results)

izi

Zuuki wrote:

izi

Too ez

Pretty questionable results, to a point that it looks like a prank taken too far. But the song pack was good, so there is that.

I am not salty, i am just not blind and can tell apart good amvs from bad amvs. Which i didnt expect to be so difficult, yet i was proved wrong.

Lightning Arrow wrote:

I am not salty, i am just not blind and can tell apart good amvs from bad amvs. Which i didnt expect to be so difficult, yet i was proved wrong.

Lightning Arrow wrote:

Pretty questionable results, to a point that it looks like a prank taken too far. But the song pack was good, so there is that.

chris thinks youre pretty

Celia Phantomhive wrote:

Lightning Arrow wrote:

I am not salty, i am just not blind and can tell apart good amvs from bad amvs. Which i didnt expect to be so difficult, yet i was proved wrong.

If i had a euro for everyone that thinks the same way Greece would go out of debt.

If i had a euro for every good amv you've made i would be homeless.

a guy who i thought would be bellow middle is 4th oooook

That makes two of us i guess

So apparently all you need is 2+ minutes, a story and maybe some fame to get a good rating in this IC..
I really don't get these results because the criteria are veeeeery vage. You should also have told us what you judge the videos on.
I thought action would mostly be judged on flow, impact and scene selection, but instead I got "editing" - could literally mean anything - "concept" - so you suddenly want me to make some sort of story? - and "enjoyability" - a reeeaaally subjective criteria as it completely depends on the person. You should also have made the criteria category-specific since - as I already said - action mainly depends on flow and stuff, while fun depends on funny things, romance on atmosphere etc...
It's really depressing to put a whole weekend of constant editing into scene selection (I made fairly many links), masking and pan / cropping to create a nice flow, just to see this video get destroyed by hardly edited videos that were made without much effort, only because you don't like my style and I didn't create a real story or simply because of something I had and still have no chance to know since everything is so vage.

Pieetrr wrote:

That makes two of us i guess

If this is referring to my reply, you are free to stay in your utopian world.
Good night :)

It's clear who is the delusional one in here.Pro judge straight out of the eggshell.

Best dance and 19th place? Hmmmm

luciole 4th ldsgalkalgj';jkfE;KJF;'kfEF;'K;QEf;q bam bam jurgbrlarakwlhewk

Zyrix wrote:

So apparently all you need is 2+ minutes, a story and maybe some fame to get a good rating in this IC..
I really don't get these results because the criteria are veeeeery vage. You should also have told us what you judge the videos on.
I thought action would mostly be judged on flow, impact and scene selection, but instead I got "editing" - could literally mean anything - "concept" - so you suddenly want me to make some sort of story? - and "enjoyability" - a reeeaaally subjective criteria as it completely depends on the person. You should also have made the criteria category-specific since - as I already said - action mainly depends on flow and stuff, while fun depends on funny things, romance on atmosphere etc...
It's really depressing to put a whole weekend of constant editing into scene selection (I made fairly many links), masking and pan / cropping to create a nice flow, just to see this video get destroyed by hardly edited videos that were made without much effort, only because you don't like my style and I didn't create a real story or simply because of something I had and still have no chance to know since everything is so vage.

Editing: Flow, scene selection, transitioning, effect usage, visual/audio quality
Concept: Emotion, impact, atmosphere, theme or storyline portrayed, category relevance, song/source combination
Enjoyability: how well everything came together to make an enjoyable AMV

mate

would you like a video critique? I'd be happy to provide one for you if it would help

Spoiler:

I haven't watched many of the vids so i wont talk about the judging etc, but you can be 1st in dance and 19th on overall, it makes sense.

I had fun and I'm happy with the result but tbh the salt post result is definitely more interesting