Is Angel Beats good? [Spoilers in brackets,cleaned]

I remember Nikos recommending this show to me.. is it worth the watch ?

FilmZ wrote:

I remember Nikos recommending this show to me.. is it worth the watch ?

i don't remember what i told you exactly but it got me hooked up till the end ,it got some plotholes but it's really good and emotional
and since you 've been getting so emotional with mirai nikki i think you are gonna love it , some manly tears where shed with the ending
and at some point in the middle of the anime (it's only 12 episodes ) and i don't get emotional with animes , the only time i did was in code geass
ending and with somebodys death in guilty crown

Spoiler:

other than angel beats

Angel Beats...aaaah teh memories :( :( Definetely watch that...For me its 8-9/10 :rendeer: :rendeer:

TheInvisibleBlackxX wrote:

Angel Beats...aaaah teh memories :( :( Definetely watch that...For me its 8-9/10 :rendeer: :rendeer:

i agree, at least 8/10 , maybe some things don't make so much sense that's why it's not a 9 or a 10

NO,it's not good,it's cheap. 5/10 from me.

but you gonna like it because it's made for teen girls,so no point in me whining.

I feel like i'm the only person in the world that really doesn't get moved by life failures,and cheap emotional moments.

sgtpeterarbit wrote:

NO,it's not good,it's cheap. 5/10 from me.

but you gonna like it because it's made for teen girls,so no point in me whining.

I feel like i'm the only person in the world that really doesn't get moved by life failures,and cheap emotional moments.

i could agree on the "it's made for teen girls" but i also liked it so maybe it's not as bad as you think...ofcourse opinions but not a 5,
at least 6.5 if i see it from your pov

nikos150 wrote:

sgtpeterarbit wrote:

NO,it's not good,it's cheap. 5/10 from me.

but you gonna like it because it's made for teen girls,so no point in me whining.

I feel like i'm the only person in the world that really doesn't get moved by life failures,and cheap emotional moments.

i could agree on the "it's made for teen girls" but i also liked it so maybe it's not as bad as you think...ofcourse opinions but not a 5,
at least 6.5 if i see it from your pov

Le setting is ridiculous

Le plot is ridiculous

I don't remembermuch related to character development because i watched it like a year ago,maybe the only plus point.

And that it's a highly rated anime,with a big fanbase which makes it look even worse.

Only excuse is that i'm not in the pool of viewers that's headed towards to.

5/10 because really nothing interesting on this anime for me as an individual to watch,character development for me personally was totally indifferent,and maybe a lil' bit annoying.

Spoiler:

I won't cry,sorry,your effort was pointless,like trying to make me affectionate with 3-4 cases in 12 eps was quite hillarious.

sgtpeterarbit wrote:

nikos150 wrote:

sgtpeterarbit wrote:

NO,it's not good,it's cheap. 5/10 from me.

but you gonna like it because it's made for teen girls,so no point in me whining.

I feel like i'm the only person in the world that really doesn't get moved by life failures,and cheap emotional moments.

i could agree on the "it's made for teen girls" but i also liked it so maybe it's not as bad as you think...ofcourse opinions but not a 5,
at least 6.5 if i see it from your pov

Le setting is ridiculous

Le plot is ridiculous

I don't remembermuch related to character development because i watched it like a year ago,maybe the only plus point.

And that it's a highly rated anime,with a big fanbase which makes it look even worse.

Only excuse is that i'm not in the pool of viewers that's headed towards to.

5/10 because really nothing interesting on this anime for me as an individual to watch,character development for me personally was totally indifferent,and maybe a lil' bit annoying.

Spoiler:

.I won't cry,sorry,your effort was pointless,

Spoiler:

.

first of all don't spoil and secondly , i guess you always rate the anime as a whole and not in the way it looked to you while you were watching it...i don't know about you, but me plus 2 of my friends that are definitely not the type of guys that cry , not in anime, but in any serie,movie etc. cried in the end so for a drama anime i think it served it's purpose very good

And here comes tough guy Peter saying it didn't make me go all affectionate and emotional as other really well executed anime like 5cm/s and Clannad.It simply failed to do that for me.That's why my personal rating for this show is no less than 5/10.It's ok saying that you liked A LOT,but don't tell me that my rating should be min 6.5/10.

sgtpeterarbit wrote:

And here comes tough guy Peter saying it didn't make me go all affectionate and emotional as other really well executed anime like 5cm/s and Clannad.It simply failed to do that for me.That's why my personal rating for this show is no less than 5/10.It's ok saying that you liked A LOT,but don't tell me that my rating should be min 6.5/10.

i didn't say i am the emotional guy and you are with heart made of rock but i am just saying that it can serve it's purpose as a drama and for that
it deserves more than 6...btw i ve been hearing about clannad since i finished angel beats but i haven't been in the mood for a drama anime till
now but i heared it's great, maybe i should start it now since i am bored

P.S please put the spoils into spoiler , i know they are small but they are still considered as spoils

have watched 6 eps
a good 4/10 for now

EDIT.
Finished it.


Was this show supposed to make cry ? Warawaseru na! Didn't even feel sorry for any of them. And I kinda felt bad because everyone said I was supposed to cry but I didn't O_o
Anyway 5/10
Not gonna re-watch.

and just for the record mirai nikki was way sadder
:p

Okay,so i cleaned this mess,i was in a bad mood then so there was a lot of rage-typing.Definitely a sadder theme than Mirai Nikki but still not anime that i'd recommend to anyone except to highschool teens.

MIRAI NIKKI IS THE BEST, BITCH

mirai nikki is half as bad as SAO (and SAO is extremely bad)

I think Mirai Nikki was better anime than SAO,because SAO was crap incarnate but still Mirai Nikki is really mediocre,start was really good but didn't like the rest

sgtpeterarbit wrote:

I think Mirai Nikki was better anime than SAO,because SAO was crap incarnate but still Mirai Nikki is really mediocre,start was really good but didn't like the rest

that

I want to see angel beats too but now i have exams :/ (also after that i want to watch 5cm/s and maji)